Hevron, the city of Sabbateans – Part I
The Rav gave a bunch of interesting ‘clues’ about who is running things in the Holy Land, from behind the scenes, in the last shiur of his I translated.
(Read the lengthier excerpt HERE.)
As well as touching on more of the real story about how the charidee money apparently was getting siphoned-off into private pockets almost right from the start (more about that another time….) – he also widened out the focus to start looking at what was really going on in Hevron.
Let’s bring that snippet, below, and then we’ll start to unpack it all, with God’s help:
==
There are four holy cities [in Eretz Yisrael].
Four cities: Hevron – there, there was the Rav Mani[1]. HaRav Mani was the Chief Rabbi of Hevron, there, there were all the rabbonim.
There was there the ‘Chessed L’Avraham’, and there was there the ‘Sdei Chemed’ – he’s buried in Hevron still today.
The rabbis came to visit him [the Sdei Chemed], he said: “Stay here, don’t go back to Russia.”
==
And he was the Chief Rabbi of Crimea.
Because they suspected him in Istanbul, they suspected him. They paid money to the cleaner, who cleaned the synagogue, they paid her an enormous sum of money.
In the end, he confessed to the Beit Din that she was paid money, but he’d already lost the Chief Rabbi [position] in Istanbul.
==
He was the greatest rav of all the generations, in the whole world.
He [wrote] like that, 14 books, ‘Sdei Chemed’, but his opponents, his detractors, succeeded in kicking him out of Istanbul, with false accusations.
He was the Rav of Crimea, and in the end he decided that he wanted dafka to be in Eretz Yisrael, to be buried in Hevron, next to the ‘Reishit Chochma’.
==
And so, he came to Hevron.
The rabbis came from Crimea, there were also chief rabbis. He said to them:
Stay here, if you go back – nothing will remain of you.
And so it was. Everyone went back, and not even a single child remains. All of them ascended al kiddush Hashem (were killed in the sanctification of God’s name.)
Part of them became communists, part the Nazis murdered.
The Nazis slaughtered all the Jews, six million Jews.
==
I knew as soon as I read all this stuff the first time around, that a huge bunch of new info was about to start swinging loose, when I started trying to bottom all this information out.
And yup…. That’s definitely what happened.
Let’s start with a bit more background about Hevron, taken from a book in French called:
Le Livre de Hebron, by Eliaou Attlan – a resident of Hebron.
==
Why was I reading a book in French? Because I was in Hevron over Sukkot 5784, and at the little kiosk that sells books by the bottom of the steps, I was trying to get hold of a book of the history of Hevron in English.
The bookseller told me that to his knowledge, it doesn’t exist.
But he had something in French, if I could read French well enough (long story short, I can. Finally, I start to understand why I had to learn French….)
==
In Attlan’s book, I learned the following:
Hevron was a hotbed of Sabbatean messianic fervor.
Shabtai Tzvi / the SHACH himself was a shadar, or ‘emissary’ raising funds for Eretz Yisrael before Nathan of Gaza ‘announced’ him as moshiach, and before he left to fundraise in Egypt, in 1664, he came to Hebron.
That’s where Shabtai Tzvi made one of his most ardent followers, the Hebron Sage R AVRAHAM CUENQUE – who was also frequently employed as a fundraising shadar, for Eretz Yisrael.
Remember, all this predates the aliyah of the Sabbatean YEHUDA CHASSID, and his bunch of merry Sabbateans, by at least 50 years. And it predates the Chassidic Aliyah of 1772 by more than a century.
==
According to Attlan, R CUENQUE was known as an honest, erudite and pious man.
And SHABTAI TZVI caught him totally, in his net.
This is my English translation of the passgge Attlan brings in his book, on page 104, describing R CUENQUE’s reaction to meeting SHABTAI TZVI:
“I couldn’t stop staring at his eyes, He prayed the mincha service in the heart of our holy community, then the whole community followed him for the evening prayers to close by the Cave of the Machpela.[2]
“Almost the whole night, I stayed there, outside the house where he was lodging, espying like this each one of his gestures. All those who lived in the Quarter, men, women and their children – no-one thought of sleeping that night, we were all there watching him.
“He (Shabtai Tzvi) walked inside the room, alternating between large strides and small steps. The whole house was bathed in the light of candles, because this was his will. All night long, at the top of his lungs, he recited Psalms from memory. A voice imprinted with joy and emotion, radiant and beautiful to hear.
“This [continued] until the first light of dawn…. I can attest just how much this man appeared strange to me. I remember that my eyes didn’t cease to observe him avidly. After the morning prayers, he left, accompanied by just one servant….he left the city, and my eyes have no longer had the privilege of seeing him, until this day.”
==
You wouldn’t know it from the rosy description in Attlan’s book, but Yaakov Emden had a very different view of ABRAHAM CUENQUE of Hevron.
(Not for the faint-hearted….)
This snippet comes from the introduction to David Halpern’s book: Fourth Testimony – The Biography of Abraham Cuenque:
‘A PEDDLER who tramped from town to town filling his hands with the wealth of the scattered Jewish people … a slick-tongued rascal who caught his prey with his jaws … like a pig stretching out its hooves … like a slut spreading her legs for every passer-by, copulating with donkeys … ‘.
This is how the anti-Sabbatian crusader Jacob Emden described Abraham Cuenque, in his preface to the first publication (1752) of Cuenque’s sixty year- old biography of Sabbatai Zevi.
==
Gaza is where Nathan of Gaza was hanging out, with Shabtai Tzvi, proclaiming his ‘messiah-ship’.
Gaza and Hevron enjoyed very close relations at that point, so Hevron was the next city to acclaim Shabtai Tzvi as ‘the moshiach’ – and they did so with unparalleled enthusiasm.
Then, according to Attlan, the [formerly converso…) rabbis of Hevron sent a long letter to their (formerly converso….) wealthy funders in Amsterdam, the Pereira family, telling them ‘the moshiach has arrived’.
The rabbis told the Pereiras to liquidate their holdings, and move to Eretz Yisrael.
==
The patriach of the Pereiras, AVRAHAM PEREIRA, was actually on the way to Israel, when news came that ‘the moshiach’ had converted to Islam….
While this dampened a lot of the enthusiasm around Shabtai Tzvi in a lot of places (or at least, and more accurately, drove the belief in his ‘moshiach-ness’ underground….) – in Hevron, they didn’t seem to mind so much.
The kabbalists of Hevron led the way with more spiritual gymnastics, explaining that the conversion to Islam was necessary for the ‘second stage’ of the Moshiach’s revelation in the world.
==
Long story short: Hevron was full of die-hard Sabbateans from this time on.
‘Official history’ likes to scrub a lot of these people out of the story, because when they are restored to their proper locations in the story of the Jewish people, and particularly, the story of what was really happening here in the Holy Land, a whole bunch of other uncomfortable information starts to come into focus.
So, R AVRAHAM PEREIRA is a strong Sabbatean, a former converso living in Amsterdam and funding a whole bunch of things in Israel, including the ‘Or HaTorah’ yeshiva in JERUSALEM – and also the printing press in Amsterdam, where he installs none other than MANASSEH BEN ISRAEL, to oversee the project.[3]
In 1659 – a few years before SHABTAI TZVI comes on the scene – two of the shadarim from Hevron, called MEIR ROFEH and YEHUDA ZEV, persuade Pereira to start donating large chunks of his fortune to their community.
That’s when PEREIRA founds the ‘CHESED L’AVRAHAM’ yeshiva in Hevron.
And he makes MEIR HIYYA ROFE the Rosh Yeshiva.
==
MEIR HIYYA ROFE is also known to have become a very enthusiastic follower of SHABTAI TZVI.
He writes to PEREIRA in 1665 that:
“[A] man who possesses the Holy Spirit, who responds to the name Nathan, came to tell us certain revelations….”
I.e. That SHABTAI TZVI was the moshiach.
Rofe encourages Pereira to move to Israel.
==
This snippet comes from the Wiki site for MEIR HIYYA ROFE, HERE:
Meir maintained his belief even after Sabbatai’s conversion in 1666.
In 1672 Meir left, again as an emissary of Hebron, for Turkey. He stayed for a time in Adrianople, where he was in contact with Sabbatai. On Sabbatai’s exile to Albania in 1673, Meir returned to Gaza where he stayed with Nathan and even copied his writings for his own use.
He then traveled again to Italy, and from 1675 to 1678 resided in the home of the Sabbatean Abraham Rovigo in Modena.
Throughout his stay in Italy Meir did much to encourage those who believed in Sabbatai Zevi and spread the writings of Nathan of Gaza.
During the last ten years of his life he was recognized as the outstanding scholar of Hebron.
==
MEIR ROFE was a very serious, missionising ‘prophet’ of Sabbateanism for decades.
AND, apparently, ‘the outstanding scholar of Hebron’.
Remember, he was running the CHESSED L’AVRAHAM yeshiva – if the Rosh Yeshiva was such a prominent Sabbatean, you can be sure the yeshiva was turning out lots and lots of ‘little Sabbateans’, too.
==
AVRAHAM PEREIRA dies in 1699, and one of his son’s YAAKOV PEREIRA takes over the family fortune – and expands the (Sabbatean….) yeshiva in Hevron, now calling it:
CHESSED L’AVRAHAM VE EMET LE YAAKOV.
==
Let’s just pick up a bit of info about the original CHESSED L’AVRAHAM while we’re here – also mentioned by the Rav like this:
Four cities: Hevron – there, there was the Rav Mani. HaRav Mani was the Chief Rabbi of Hevron, there, there were all the rabbonim.
There was there the ‘Chessed L’Avraham’, and there was there the ‘Sdei Chemed’ – he’s buried in Hevron still today.
==
According to the YeshShem.com website, the CHESSED L’AVRAHAM was R AVRAHAM AZULAI.
He was born in Fez, Morocco, in 1570, and he dies in Hevron in 1643. He’s a big kabbalist, writes a book called the CHESSED L’AVRAHAM – and is the great-grandpa of the CHIDA.
Interestingly, according to the DailyZohar.com site:
One of the most important achievements of R’ Azulai was excavating R’ Chaim Vital’s manuscripts (later known as Etz Chaim) from his tomb in Damascus (Syria).
Together with another kabbalist of the time Rabbi Yaacov Tzemach, Rabbi Avraham Azulai dealt with Yichudim (special Kabbalistic meditations) and She’alot Chalom (dream meditation) until permission was granted to them by R’ Chaim Vital to dig at his grave.
==
This ‘excavating’ of R CHAIM VITAL’s kabbalistic manuscripts from his grave, solely based on a ‘dream’, was not uncontroversial, to say the least.
I’m not going to ‘deep dive’ on that subject in these posts, but take a look at the controversy around YISRAEL of SARUG.
YAAKOV TZEMACH is said to be the student of SHMUEL VITAL – R Chaim’s son in Egypt….. And another famous follower of SHABTAI TZVI….
==
Tov.
As usual with this stuff, I’ve just hit another patch of unexpected interesting.
This is a scan of the picture Attlan includes in chapter on ‘Le Gvir Peyrera’, with the description that this is meant to be a portrait of Pereira’s friend and collaborator in Hevron, Dr EPHRAIM BUENO – as painted by REMBRANDT.
(It’s definitely not BUENO – read on. If anyone can help me track down this sketch, below, I’d be very grateful.)
====
This guy looks like a dead ringer for the court Jew SAMUEL OPPENHEIMER, whose descendants include the Sabbatean-funding WERTHEIMERS….
This is a picture of SAMUEL OPPENHEIMER:
And so is this:
==
And this is the picture of DR EPHRAIM BUENO, as painted by Rembrandt (who also sketched MANASSEH BEN ISRAEL, and had his salary paid by ABRAHAM PEREIRA):

Rembrandt * Portrait of a man, presumably Dr. Ephraïm Bueno (1599–1665) * ca. 1647 * oil on panel * 19 × 15 cm * Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum Amsterdam
As you can see – they are totally different people.
==
At this point, I remembered I did a whole ‘deep dive’ last year on this same SAMUEL OPPENHEIMER – who converted out to xtianity and became the Judaism-hating JOHANN EISENMENGER.
Go and read that HERE.
That happened a lot with the people who were pushing the ‘false messiahs’ down Jewish history. When things didn’t pan out the way they hoped, they got yeoush and many converted to xtianity.
There is nothing new under the sun.
==
OK, last couple of things to pick up over here, by ABRAHAM PEREIRA and his little Sabbatean buddies of Hevron, before we move on to R MANI of Hevron, in the next post.
I was trying to figure out IF the super-wealthy PEREIRAs of Amsterdam are actually a pseudonym (or vice-versa) for the super-wealthy OPPENHEIM court Jews of Vienna.
That took me over to ABRAHAM PEREIRA’S family tree on Geni – which I got to from this snippet from the Jewish Encyclopaedia site, HERE:
Pereyra left five sons, Isaac, Jacob, Moses, Aaron, and David, and two daughters, Ribca, wife of Jacob de Pinto, and Rachel, wife of Abraham Cuitiño (Quitiño)
==
This is the screenshot for RIBCA PEREIRA, wife of JACOB de PINTO.
==
She has another husband called ISAAC DE MATOS – this is the ancestor of none other than MOSES MONTEFIORE.
That info has been carefully scrubbed off, so that most people will have no idea that it’s always the same people, when it comes to Eretz Yisrael and ruling the Jewish community.
==
Meanwhile, ABRAHAM PEREIRA has a very interesting brother, called:
Salvador (Abraham) Vaez Martinez
He’s a KNIGHT OF ALCANTARA – and like you, I also had absolutely no idea what that actually was.
==
If you go HERE, you can read up about it, a little, on the Wiki page for the ORDER OF ALCANTARA.
Snippet:
The Order of Alcántara, also called the Knights of St. Julian, was originally a military order of León, founded in 1166 and confirmed by Pope Alexander III in 1177….
This order’s genesis is obscure, but according to a somewhat questionable tradition, St. Julian de Pereiro was a hermit of the country of Salamanca, where by his counsel, some knights built a castle on the river Tagus to oppose the Muslims….
The Knights of Alcántara, under their new name, acquired many castles and estates, for the most part at the expense of the Muslims. They amassed great wealth from booty during the war and from pious donations…..
The Knights of Alcántara were released from the vow of celibacy by the Holy See in 1540, and the ties of common life were sundered.
==
The PEREIRA family have the same surname as this Order’s founder, JULIAN DE PEREIRO.
I am willing to bet good money that there are tight links between this group, and the Jesuits and their secret orders, and today’s frankist-masons.
That happened when these catholic-conversos-with-cash got ‘reabsorbed’ into the Jewish community in the 17th century – and then literally took over the leadership with their ideas, connections and money.
And then started the process of subverting the Jewish community from within.
==
OK, let’s stop there for Part One of this expose on the ‘real Jewish history’ of Hevron.
And remember, we’re only just getting started on the subject. There are still a lot more secrets buried in the City of the Patriarchs, waiting to be uncovered.
TBC
====
FOOTNOTES:
[2] Probably referring to the 7th step in Hevron, as Jews were not allowed to enter the tomb itself, at this point in history.
[3] Who you’ll recall, was the ‘figurehead’ used in the PR campaign to get the Jews readmitted to the UK, on behalf of the formerly converso-catholics-now-back-as-jews, who seem to have been running so much of the show for the last 500 years, from behind the scenes.
As of late, I’ve been very afraid and uneasy about how the wicked people are planning to enslave us, and I am having difficulty trusting in God that He will save us from these people, even though apparently the messiah the Rav will be revealed openly in two months.
What should I do to stop being afraid and trust in God.
None of us know what tomorrow is going to bring, which is why Chazal teach a person should make teshuva ‘the die before they die’ -i.e. every single day, because who knows what tomorrow brings?
Every honest, aware, person is at least a little bit afraid at the moment. I know I am, at least some of the time. When the fear gets too much, I talk to God about it in hitbodedut – and then I start to feel much better and much calmer again.
At the end of the day, God is the one deciding, who lives, and who dies.
It’s an uncomfortable truth, but it’s the truth.
And God has got the whole picture, including the spiritual tikkun our soul required, firmly in view, when making those decisions.
So, we do our best to stay close to God, to follow His laws, to keep speaking to Him every single day for our mental health – and then, the other 23 hours a day, we do our best to live our lives fully, and with joy.
The fear damages way more than anything else.
You are doing your best spiritually, Simon. And this is God’s world, and He’s taking a very close, minute interest in everything and everyone.
R Elmaliach said in one of his classes on the Tower of Bavel that God let the Evils build it, and think that they were going to succeed right up until the very last minute…. before He stepped in and destroyed the whole enterprise.
That was part of their punishment, to work so hard and get nowhere, ultimately.
BH, history will repeat itself, in a good way.
Simon: Just like He’s letting the Evils today build their World Economic Forum and worldwide financial scheme, etc., and soon it will all come crashing down on them.
(Rivka, I suspect this is why the angels wouldn’t let the Rav push off geula for another 6 years. They’re almost ready.)
Interesting that you think the shach was actually shabbtai tzvi…what about the fact that we follow his psakim and his commentary on the shu”a is universally accepted?
That idea has an awful lot of information to support it.
And if you see what happened with the Rebbe of Lubavitch, recently, it’s obvious that a ‘potential messiah’ has to have a convincing CV, in order for people to follow them, even mistakenly.
==
In terms of why we ‘follow’ the rabbis we follow – there has always been a concerted effort to ensure that we are ‘following’ rabbis who are working for the machine.
The rabbis who don’t ‘work for the machine’ – which were the royalty, nobles and church figures of the past, and whatever they have now morphed into, behind the scenes, today – don’t get their books published, don’t get their names lit up in lights, and don’t get tons of good PR.
Just look at what happened with Jonathan Sacks.
weird…interesting theory…who exactly makes this concerted effort? also the fact remains that everyone follows all these people, from the way we kasher our keilim to the way we perform kiddushin.
also i think any effort to cover up shabbtai tzvis real identity would be difficult with the amount of publicity around him. youd have to convince thousands of people to lie to their closest family members and never slip up. thats just a general reason why i dont believe many conspiracy theories…people are terrible at lying competently
Joe (and ‘james’) Taylor – have you never heard of ‘Acher’, Elisha ben Abuya, who was one of the greatest sages of the generation, but still ‘went bad’?
We still learn out lessons from his Torah – it’s R Meir Baal HaNess’s approach of picking the seeds from the pomegranate and discarding the rest.
Even ‘Oto HaIsh’ – as referred to in the Gemara – was a top yeshiva student who ‘went bad’.
There is a ton of precedent for this, because the higher you go, especially with kabbalah, the lower you can fall – and drag others after you.
There have been so many ‘false’ and ‘failed’ messiahs in Jewish history, and they all had a reputation, deserved or not, for erudition and being a Torah sage / rabbi / important Jewish leader, on some level, before ‘going bad’.
I will re-post the main articles about the SHACH from a couple of years ago, that pulls a lot of the info together. And since then, I have learned so many more things that support the theory, such as pretty much EVERY Frankist-mason-maskil I write about descends from the SHACH.
It’s the same people writing our ‘history’ by the way. And falsifying history is so easy, because even at the time, most people don’t know what’s going on, really, or don’t care.
Fudging history, especially in a time when there was no mass media, no pictures, no way of keeping things ‘recorded’ for most individuals except orally – is the easiest thing in the world.
When people start throwing around the phrase ‘conspiracy theory’ without even engaging with simple information, simple facts, it suggests they aren’t interested in knowing what’s true, but just in shutting other people up who are questioning the narrative.
Was ‘Acher’ also a conspiracy theory – a leading sage who went bad, who then had his name blotted out of history?
r’ nachman says that learning shach is a segulah for clearing up the bilbulim, i guess im just confused about how that fits with what youre saying.
what i mean by conspiracy theory, isnt that its not true, just that youre alleging that people conspired to cover up history etc.
when was achers name blotted out of history? also the point the gemara is making is that you have to be rabbi meir baal hanes to learn ochel min hapsoles, i doubt later generations knew what they were doing.
im not sure what u mean by frankist mason maskil who are these people?
im open to understanding your theories but i do need to ask questions and think critically, as im sure you understand. this isnt just to argue for no reason.
im obviously not going to use my real name online
If the questions are coming from an honest place, I welcome them.
First, can you tell me where Rabbenu says that about the Shach? What’s the source? What I learned is that Rabbenu said learning halacha – Shulchan Aruch – is what helps to do the birur between ‘good and bad’. Are you referring to this, or something that specifically refers to the Shach?
In terms of people conspiring to cover up history… take a look at what we are living through right now, with the massacre that occurred on Simchat Torah.
Do you believe the truth of what happened on that day has come out, or are people conspiring to cover it up?
If you don’t know who the Frankist-Mason-Maskilim are, I guess you are a new reader…. there’s a lot to catch up, but to put it at its most basic, the Frankists were a sub-group of the Sabbateans, who went after Jacob Frank and went down a very evil path where masonic satanism and xtianity and twisted kabbalah got all mixed up.
Many of the Frankists converted outwardly to xtianity – but many didn’t. And of those that didn’t, they continued to shape the Jewish community with their money and connections and masonic-satanic ideas.
Many of the Frankist-masons overlap with the leading maskilim.
And while all that was going on, the old-school Sabbateans were also still in the mix, and to be found in most of the leadership positions of what we would call the ‘orthodox world’.
interesting idea….who exactly is pushing these rabbis? all our tzaddikim have approved of the shach as far as i know
its in sefer hamiddot, da’at, chelek alef, number 3 – “גם לימוד ש”ך [שפתי כהן] סגלה לזה, גם אכילת חטים”
yeah i kinda believe about october 7th, what exactly do you think they’re covering up?
whats the evidence that “most of the leadership positions of what we would call the ‘orthodox world’” are frankists and sabbateans? even in those times it was very rare that they made it into mainstream judaism without being discovered, as is known about r’ yonasan eybeshitz who probably wasnt even an actual full blown sabbatean.
id welcome some links to earlier posts that are relevant if thats ok
Thanks for the source.
The difficulty is that I’ve been researching this, and literally putting up hundreds of posts, over the last 4 1/2 years, each one of which covers a bit more of the subject.
So, giving ‘the evidence’ in a few sentences in a comment is quite an ask.
Another commentator suggested I pull all the info into a book, and it could be it’s approaching the time to do that.
In the meantime, if you follow the posts I’m doing right now on what was going on in Hevron (for example), you’ll start to get a flavor of how detailed all this actually is, and how ‘real Jewish history’ is very different from the ‘official history’ we’ve all been taught.
And when I have a bit more koach, I will put up some of my older posts, maybe just collated as a PDF, as a starting point.
sure looking forward
interested to hear your thoughts on that source, i think r’ natan mentions a similar idea and is quite praiseworthy of the shach in likkutei halachot
You know Rabbenu’s lesson of Azamra…. how finding the ‘good points’ returns the person to the side of merit…